Safety Review: MAIB Report on the 2023 Honeybourne III Chain Failure
Safety review of MAIB report 1/2026 (published 15 Jan 2026) on the October 2023 Honeybourne III chain failure: static-pin risk and inspection gaps.
IMPACT SNAPSHOTRISK
- Who is affected
- Worldwide
This is a technical safety review, not breaking news. It draws on MAIB Accident Investigation Report 1/2026, published on 15 January 2026, into an accident that happened on 6 October 2023.
The accident
On 6 October 2023, a deckhand aboard the scallop dredger Honeybourne III (PD905) died after a towing block fell from the head of the port derrick. A section of chain supporting the fishing gear failed, and the suspended gear fell to the deck.
The UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) published Accident Investigation Report 1/2026 on the accident on 15 January 2026. MAIB found that high loading and bending moments in the outer links of the quick-release assembly increased stress where the chain passed over a static pin. The report says the material hardness likely reduced the strength of the chain links on the port quick-release gear. The vessel’s onboard lifting-equipment inspection programme did not identify patent defects before the failure.
After the accident, MAIB issued Safety Bulletin 1/2024. It urged owners and operators of beam and scallop trawlers to inspect quick-release arrangements. MAIB also recommended that the Maritime and Coastguard Agency use its powers under sections 261 and 262 of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995 to reduce the substantial risk from chains led over a static pin as the sole support for a suspended load. The agency should also update surveyor guidance to verify that operators have completed the actions in Safety Bulletin 20.
Who is affected
The finding concerns owners and operators of beam and scallop trawlers that use quick-release gear with chain led over a static pin. Technical managers, superintendents, and HSQE staff who set or audit inspection checklists for towing and lifting gear also need to review the report.
Why it matters
MAIB found that the onboard inspection programme did not identify patent defects in Honeybourne III’s lifting equipment. The chain’s route over a static pin and the likely reduction in material hardness created a failure mode that routine visual checks did not identify.
Technical managers should check whether documented inspection procedures cover material hardness, fatigue, and stress concentration at static pins. A fleet that relies on visual checks without those checks may have the same gap.
Safety lessons: what to check
- Identify vessels that use quick-release towing or lifting arrangements with chain led over a static pin. Check them against MAIB Safety Bulletin 1/2024 and Safety Bulletin 20.
- Review onboard lifting-equipment inspection procedures against MAIB’s finding that the programme did not identify patent defects. Check whether procedures cover material hardness and stress concentration at pins as well as visual wear.
- For static-pin quick-release designs that remain in use, have a superintendent review whether equipment or operating-procedure changes are needed. Keep the record for any MCA follow-up under the Merchant Shipping Act 1995 powers in the recommendations.
PRIMARY SOURCE
Spot an error? Request a correction
Apeks Tech Editorial Team
Sourced curation
The Apeks Tech editorial team — sourced briefs and engineering-led curation; sources are listed on every brief. Editorial policy →
Forward this to a colleague
Should your DPA, technical superintendent or a fellow owner see this? Forwarding costs nothing.
Was this forwarded to you? Take your own copy → subscribe here.