Analysis: Why NZF Incentives for ZNZ Fuels Need Fuel-by-Fuel Design
Technical analysis of a Shipping and Oceans FAQ: why IMO Net Zero Framework incentives for zero/near-zero fuels need fuel-specific design.
This is a technical analysis, not a news report. It reviews an undated FAQ published by Shipping and Oceans on the IMO’s Net Zero Framework; no new IMO decision or event is reported here.
According to Shipping and Oceans, a FAQ on the IMO’s Net Zero Framework (NZF) says incentives for Zero-or-Near-Zero (ZNZ) fuels need to vary by fuel type. A single level would favour the ZNZ fuel with the lowest current cost and would not remain technology-agnostic.
The core argument
Shipping and Oceans says ZNZ fuels differ in capital and operating costs and in their reliance on new shore-side infrastructure. One incentive level cannot serve each fuel type equally. It may also amplify risks linked to particular ZNZ fuels, including environmental integrity, Surplus Unit (SU) market stability, and fund liability exposure.
Shipping and Oceans says multiplier-based incentives increase emissions compared with a reward mechanism or no incentive because operators can meet GFI compliance with less actual GHG reduction. It says higher GFI trajectories, especially in early compliance periods, would need to offset that effect. Multipliers may also create an oversupply of SUs, lower SU prices, and delay incentives for direct compliance. The FAQ calls for sunset clauses or equivalent guardrails.
Fuel-by-fuel assessment
Shipping and Oceans assesses the Chinese GFI multiplier and the Norwegian SU multiplier. It finds the Chinese multiplier works well for shore power, wind assistance, and drop-in biofuels. Those ZNZ options have a viable business case at a modest share, around 25% or less, of a ship’s annual energy use. The FAQ says the Chinese multiplier does not work as well for batteries, e-fuels, or nuclear.
The Norwegian multiplier can support e-fuels and nuclear. Shipping and Oceans says it is more likely to need early guardrails where it incentivises drop-in biofuels, wind assistance, or electrification because of SU oversupply risk.
Under many modelled scenarios, Shipping and Oceans says the incentive levels proposed by China and Norway would not drive ZNZ-fuel uptake, particularly for e-fuels.
Design options and transition phases
Shipping and Oceans says Just Energy Transition (JET) risks vary with the incentive mechanism. Differentiation or sunset clauses can reduce those risks. JET outcomes could improve if JET eligibility serves as an additional criterion for allocating incentives under multiplier or reward-based designs.
The FAQ says a reverse auction can provide cost-effectiveness and predictable reward rates, supporting investor confidence in long-term ZNZ offtake. It remains less clear whether other incentive options can provide the same predictability.
Shipping and Oceans says incentive mechanisms perform differently across transition phases. Multipliers become more reliable after the SU market is established and before ZNZ use grows too large. IMO-defined reward rates offer the greatest predictability early on, then lose reliability if liability-management clauses, such as discount rates or carry-forwards, take effect.
The FAQ suggests a combination approach: the Chinese GFI multiplier for partial-share solutions such as drop-in biofuel, wind assistance, CCS, and shore power; targeted rewards for e-fuels, nuclear, and battery-powered ships.
Spot an error? Request a correction
Apeks Tech Editorial Team
Sourced curation
The Apeks Tech editorial team — sourced briefs and engineering-led curation; sources are listed on every brief. Editorial policy →
Forward this to a colleague
Should your DPA, technical superintendent or a fellow owner see this? Forwarding costs nothing.
Was this forwarded to you? Take your own copy → subscribe here.