apeks.tech
News · Regulation & Compliance 15 November 2026 · 3 min read

Study: shipowners' EU ETS reimbursement right largely unenforceable

Erasmus study of 24 July 2026: shipowners can't rely on the EU ETS statutory right to recover carbon costs from charterers; contracts decide.

Editorial Team

Bu haberin Türkçesi →

Illustrative photograph: Yellow industrial port cranes stand over water in Lumut, Malaysia, against a clear blue sky.
Illustrative image

DECISION BRIEFCOMPLIANCE

Who is affected
Worldwide
What to do
1) Check whether BIMCO ETS clauses are included and aligned across every contract in the charter chain, not just one link. 2) Review charterparties, management agreements and bills of lading for explicit carbon cost allocation terms rather than relying on the EU statutory reimbursement right. 3) Negotiate bespoke contract language covering price volatility, off-hire and dispute resolution where existing BIMCO clauses leave gaps.
In this article
  1. What changed
  2. Who is affected
  3. Timeline
  4. Background

In a study published on 24 July 2026, Erasmus School of Law, Erasmus University Rotterdam, found that shipowners and ship managers who pay EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) costs may be unable to recover them from the charterer that controls fuel purchasing and vessel operation, according to a release from the Shipping and Oceans Research Group.

The study, titled “EU ETS payments in shipping: parties’ responsibilities towards authorities and within the commercial chain,” describes the EU statutory reimbursement right as close to a “paper tiger” under contractual and jurisdictional conditions. The researchers say the charterparty, management agreement or bill of lading determines who pays, rather than the statutory mechanism intended to ensure cost pass-through.

What changed

Since 2024, shipping companies operating in and out of the EU have had to buy and surrender emission allowances under the EU ETS: for 50% of emissions on voyages into or out of the EU, and 100% on intra-EU voyages and at berth. The Directive makes the “shipping company” responsible, the registered owner, or a manager or bareboat charterer that has formally taken over the owner’s ISM Code duties, even if that party has little control over fuel choice, routing or speed. EU law requires Member States to provide a statutory right to reimbursement from the party that controls those decisions.

The study identifies three obstacles. In multi-layered charter chains, the Directive gives no clear rule for identifying the party that must reimburse where responsibility for cargo, route, speed and fuel is divided among charterers. Most shipping contracts use English law, and it remains uncertain whether a national reimbursement right can override that choice under the EU’s Rome I and Rome II private international law rules. Disputes also tend to go to arbitration in London or Singapore, outside EU court jurisdiction. English law provides no reimbursement mechanism, and English courts can block EU proceedings or refuse to recognise EU judgments.

Co-author Hannah Mosmans said the EU ETS “gives the impression” that shipowners can automatically recover carbon costs from the party responsible for operation or fuel purchase, but contract practice makes this “largely an illusion.”

The study also reviewed BIMCO’s standard clauses for time charters, voyage charters, contracts of affreightment, ship management agreements and bareboat charters. It found the clauses useful but incomplete. Each clause works on a bilateral basis, so each contract in a chain needs an aligned clause. The clauses leave gaps on price volatility, credit risk, off-hire and demurrage, while their optional use makes coverage depend on the relative bargaining power of owners and charterers.

Who is affected

Shipowners, ship managers, time charterers, voyage charterers and cargo interests across EU ETS-exposed trades are affected. Shipping lines have begun passing ETS surcharges to cargo interests through bill of lading and sea waybill terms. The result, the study finds, is uneven protection across the market, with better-resourced parties securing stronger terms than smaller operators.

Timeline

The EU ETS obligation on shipping companies has applied since 2024. The UK’s domestic shipping emissions trading scheme took effect on 1 July 2026 and contains no statutory reimbursement right, leaving cost allocation to charterparty drafting.

Background

Nishatabbas Rehmatulla, Principal Research Fellow and Co-Director of the Shipping and Oceans Research Group, said that by including the reimbursement right, the EU ETS Directive assumes charterers are responsible for all emissions. He added that some emissions relate to the vessel’s technical energy efficiency, where the shipowner makes most investment. According to the release, the European Commission’s EU ETS amendment proposal of 17 July 2026, which has not yet been adopted, treats the statutory mechanism as a tool for correcting the allowance reserve and shows no awareness of the shortcomings the study identifies. The IMO is developing a global Net Zero Framework with more complex carbon cost allocations.

Related coverage

Spot an error? Request a correction

Apeks Tech Editorial Team

Sourced curation

The Apeks Tech editorial team — sourced briefs and engineering-led curation; sources are listed on every brief. Editorial policy →

Was this useful?

Forward this to a colleague

Should your DPA, technical superintendent or a fellow owner see this? Forwarding costs nothing.

Was this forwarded to you? Take your own copy → subscribe here.

Share LinkedIn X

Related reading

Apeks Brief

Free

Decision intelligence for the people who run ships: what changed, who is affected, what to do.

  • One email a week — the default; you can change it anytime.
  • The week's notable developments: a headline and one line on what changed.
  • Turkish or English. Unsubscribe in one click; your address is never shared.
From the latest issue 21 November 2026
  • IMarEST seeks regulatory certainty before MEPC 85
  • MCA updates DMLC Part I form for MLC inspections
  • Greenland to ban scrubber washwater discharges from July 2027
Read the full issue →

Free, with no paid tier. We send a confirmation link first — nothing arrives until you confirm.